How much is a 1804 silver dollar coin worth. Typical counterfeit 1804 dollars have reeded edges. However it is magnetic, so I doubt it is real. Our testimony consists chiefly of dealers who are more or less interested and which would have but little weight against such evidence as above mentioned. 42 Cent/Min. Authentic ones have either lettered or plain edges and proof surfaces . Octavo. Dexter hired Philadelphia attorney Thomas DeWitt Cuyler, who filed suit against S.H. We value your privacy! The works of art would have a similar pedigree. Brent Pogue was kind enough to bring the Dexter Dollar to Denver for my talk. Stepping up to the plate, at the sale, were Mack and Brent Pogue father and son who put in a bid on the day of the sale and then went to dinner. I think the whole coin field is really happy to see this happen, itll help the whole industry to see a coin get that much excitement.. I believe you have arrived at a very wise solution of the matter. The timing just seems to be right for a million dollar coin and if theres going to be one, an 1804 dollar should be the coin.. On April 5, 1886, after the lawsuit was filed, Frossard wrote Dexter, remarking, I can only approve of your determination to test the genuineness of the 1804 dollar. However, he back-tracked on calling the coin a restrike, If proved to be an original genuine issue its value cannot be overestimated while if the contrary it would no doubt lose all its interest in your eyes & collectors generally.. Again, your 1804 dated dollar is not real. Eachof themwas attracted to a strong magnet. The U.S. Mint did not make Trade dollars prior to 1873 so you can be sure that the 1799 and 1872 Trade dollars are counterfeit as well. The 1795 Draped Bust dollar is worth around $1,000 in about good condition. Sconyers said there are no plans for immediate sale. With regards to the 1804 silver dollar, it was never a circulated coin. The following year 2000 the Dexter Dollar was put up for sale in Stacks 65th Anniversary Sale. Round Highlights: You'll marvel at the close attention to detail on this proof-quality beauty. $27.00 + $5.05 shipping. His reply, Id rather have the $10,000. Most coin dealers thought he should have bid the extra money for the publicity for the coin. Probably the most significant event concerning 1804 dollars in the decade of the 1880s took place in Berlin, Germany in October 1884, when coin dealer Adolph Weyl offered a previously unknown specimen of the 1804 in lot 159 of his 46th Auction., Heritage Auctions, from its August 9, 2013 sale of the Mickley 1804 dollar. Filed in: Coins and H. Chapman on March 15, 1886, claiming fraud and deception. The text of that letter has been published by several authors, but Ive never seen a picture of the original letter published. Laughin' 4/8/2018. Our replica coin has Exquisite workmanship, Amazing detail, and High-quality Materials, and Bring you a perfect feel. The page on the very bottom right has light circles drawn in that represent Plate II in the catalog, illustrating the 1804 dollar and the obverses and reverses of six additional high-grade dollars being offered in the sale. In early 1903 the Chapmans offered Parvin $700 cash for the dollar, but Parvin responded that he refused two other offers for $1,000 from a Chicago dealer and $1,400 from a collector. A complete set of B. Max Mehls 1941 catalog of The W.F. The King of American Coins just fetched a princely, world-record sum. . B. Max Mehl first met William Forrester Dunham in 1910 in Chicago, where Dunham lived. The only confusing thing I guess is the picture states "actual size" which is about twice the size of mine. James V. Dexter Esq. The 1803 dollar may not be as famous as the 1804, but it's held in high esteem and great respect. They are incredibly rare and sought after by people who are wealthy enough to pay millions of dollars to own one. and H. Chapman stationary. Tens and all face cards (jack [ J], queen [Q ], and king [K]) have the value of 10. The private buyer of the Dexter Dollar from the dealers who purchased the Charles M. Williams collection was Harold S. Bareford, a lawyer who became General Counsel for Warner Bros. Pictures. I think you will agree that we now have on solution, if not the solution, to the mystery of its existence, the exact date when it was struck and the reason for striking it.. Dexter, The July 1885 issue of J.W. Do you have any questions or concerns? Copies of three numismatic journal articles that are relevant to the letters are included in the collection. Thanks for adding your insight. Accordingly, the Mint director ordered the preparation of new dies -- easily identifiable as such because the denticles on the rims were 1834-style beads, not the tall, tooth-like kind found on silver dollars a generation earlier. Particular coins being offered for sale may not have been included within particular indexes, and if included, may not have experienced the same market movements as the index as a whole. So unless you are an experienced coin collector, you can best protect yourself from potentialloss by following these guidelines: If you want to be assuredthat your coins are genuine, visit our Bound Brook, NJ coin shop for a free no-obligation written appraisal. All were minted during the year's first quarter. Stacks Bowers Galleries conducted the sale with multiple auction sessions between 2015 and 2020 in cooperation with Sothebys. Gold & Silver Coin Investment vs Bitcoins. The PCGS3000 reflects the opinions of PCGSs coin price experts with respect to indexes developed by PCGS for specific coin categories. Picture Information. Hendrickson came over to Sconyers immediately after the bidding ceased. Both, the late D. Brent Pogue, a former owner of the Dexter Dollar, and I, attempted to locate these certificates. Knowledge about 1804 dollars was still being discovered at that time and much was still unknown about their disappearance. U.S. Mint records state that 19,570 silver dollars were coined in 1804; but just 15 are known. The result appears to have been simply to disgust you with collecting and putting you to great expense for nothing. The rounds measure 39 millimeters in diameter and 2.8 millimeters in thickness. I guess its just kind of a dream once you can buy something like this, coin dealer and collector Leon Hendrickson was quoted by Coin World as saying. This Collection, as a whole, is the most important collection of its kind ever offered in the nearly 150 years of American Numismatics., Of course, the outstanding coin in this Series is the 1804 Dollar. The sale was held in Berlin, Germany. In short, I feel justified in stating that this is not simply a Coin Sale Catalog, but really and truly a Library of Numismatics., This Collection, as a whole, is the most important collection of its kind ever offered in the nearly 150 years of American Numismatics.. Granberg library, which I purchased in 1983. While our testimony would have been reliable coming from Messers Frossard, Smith and Proskey still these gentlemen or at least two of them are dealers and would not have had sufficient weight before a jury to overcome the positive evidence which would have been brought forward by the Chapmans. From the day after Dexters purchase of the dollar, newspaper stories appeared across the country telling of the coins high price. Notably, his article de vertu, or prized object, was his 1804 silver dollar., Dexter has not been known in numismatic circles as an accomplished coin collector. The Dexter Dollar next appeared in the Superior Auction Galleries July 1993 Baltimore auction, where it failed to sell. The United States Mint government authorized the production of a handful of 1804 dollars for use in special presentation proof sets that were given as diplomatic gifts overseas. With one monumental exception, that was the end of the Bust dollar series, a series that had started in 1795 and was so named because it depicted a bust (and a bosomy one, at that) of Miss Liberty. Just wondering what will happen if they traced it back to you? Originally, Brenner's signature appeared on the obverse of the coin. The first ten dollar gold coins were issued by the United States in 1795 and were known as the Liberty Cap ten dollar coins. He was obviously pleased with the outcome of his legal ordeal over his 1804 Dollar. Seller: AMCoinshop Condition: REPLICA 2011 5 Oz Silver George T. Morgan Proposed Design 1876 COPY NGC Gem Proof UC OFFER: FREE CERTIFIED coins of your choice valued at up to $35 with purchase* $254.99 or Best Offer Seller: CertifiedCoins 1979 TURBAN HEAD EAGLE REPLICA PROOF Commemorative Coin LAYERED IN 24K GOLD, SPOT PLATIUM 32 GRAMS $16.25 The American Women quarters program is a series of quarters featuring notable women in U.S. history, commemorating the centennial of the Nineteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. Scotts The Coin Collectors Journal stated, regarding the 1804 silver dollar J.W. Something went wrong. In an April 1885 letter to Stickney, the Chapmans stated, We are cataloguing this one for a sale at auction., Title page of the 1885 Chapman Collection catalog with Plate I bound in the name of the collection from which J.V. 2010 - 2023 USA Coin Book. Marking the significance of this coin being made into a medallion replica to SilverTowne's history, an interesting difference for this replica medallion can be found in the ribbon in the Eagle's mouth on the reverse, instead of "E PLURIBUS UNUM" this piece says "DEXTER" and "HENDRICKSON" bringing light . United States Coins, Including 1804 Dollar. The finest example of the 1804 Class I silver dollar appeared at auction in 2016 and garnered a bid of more than $10 million but did not meet reserve and thus did not sell. Im not an expert so I just wanted to check if its possible that it is real. The Bruce Morelan Collection will be sold on October 8, 2020 by Legend. Very truly, There are four known types of 1804 dollars, including the following: 1804 Second Reverse, Class III 6 minted, 1804 Mint-Made Electrotype of Unique Plain-Edge 4 minted. American Mint offers a wide variety of collectible pieces, pick your favorite category and start collecting today. "I don't like the term `real value,'" Breen declared. Henry, H.O. I purchased it from the Stacks Bowers Galleries sale of the D. Brent Pogue numismatic library on August 7, 2020. The photos are not clear The history that shines through on these Silver U.S. rounds will undoubtedly add value to your numismatic collection. He also owned business interests in ranching, mining and real estate. All this drama has heightened the allure of the 1804 dollar; it's a coin with a compelling story to tell. Not being a coin collector I was just curious. Inventory books of his collection still exist, showing that he owned rare issues, some that were not contained in the U.S. Mint collection at the time. When the 1804 Dollar was reached everyone gave a subdued Ah! This is the most important numismatic announcement in forty years. Professional Coin Grading Services is a division of Collectors Universe, Inc. Get free numismatic news from leading coin experts, in-depth articles, market summary videos, surveys & more! Two primary differences exist between the first printing and the rewritten book. One of the best things about collecting coins is that it providesa lens through which you can explore a range of different subjects. The 1803 silver dollar with the small 3 and the 1803 silver dollar with the large 3 have similar values. America's First Silver Dollar Became the World's Most Expensive Coin When It Sold at Auction on January 24, 2013 for $10 Million! & H. Chapman, purchased October 13th, 1884, at the sale of a fine collection in Berlin. you'll find everything here at Liberty Coin. Similarly, the Chapmans built their case and recruited officials from the U.S. Mint to testify on their behalf. These Original Type coins are the most valuable of the 1804 dollar and are worth between $2 million and $4 million each. A dealer plays against one to seven players. * All prices are quoted net of the statutory value-added tax and shipping costs and possibly delivery charges, if not otherwise described. Samuel Hudson Chapman & Henry Chapman, Jr. 1804 Liberty Bust Silver Dollar COPY - 2 oz. Theodore Roosevelt was on a mission to redesign our nation's coinage. When you spend $150 or more, shipping and handling is on us. ~ Copy coin~, ANACS Shipwreck 1804 Spanish Mexico Silver 8 Reales Colonial Dollar Pirate Coin, 2019 Cook Islands 1964 Morgan Dollar Copy Silver Plated Prooflike Tribute Coin, DEXTER DOLLAR RPLICA 1804 AMERICAN MINT PROOF 20g 999 SILVER #m28, 1889 Morgan Silver Dollar (COPY) Sealed in Plastic Holder, 1) (Copy) 1849 US Liberty Silver Twenty Dollar Coin - China 01-H - Diameter 38mm, Copy 1933 Walking Liberty 20 Dollar Coin United States Gold Silver, 1804 LIBERTY BUST SILVER DOLLAR TRIBUTE PIECE, 1804 RARE Dexter Dollar SILVER King of US Coins BULLION Brilliant Uncirculated, Dollar, octagonal George III countermark (ca. Granberg owned the Idler specimen of the 1804 dollar. The gross weight of each will be slightly higher than 1/4 oz because . Amounts shown in italicized text are for items listed in currency other than U.S. dollars and are approximate conversions to U.S. dollars based upon Bloomberg's conversion rates. Fort Worth. Mark Ferguson The case was scheduled for trial on February 14th, 1887. They compared the coin to the 1804 silver dollar in the U.S. Mint collection in Philadelphia. These unique works of art The Dollar of 1804 and The 1804 Dollar are part of the Dexter Dollar Collection. Of course you will still hear adverse criticism of the coin but in such a matter all will never be convinced and my advice to you would be to dismiss the attacks upon the dollar from your mind and insist in view of the examinations made and the certificates that you have a genuine coin beyond question. It carries a legal tender value of $10. It more than doubled the previous price record for a single coin sold at public auction for another 1804 silver dollar. Save 1804 silver dollar copy to get e-mail alerts and updates on your eBay Feed. Williams owned many important rarities, including the unique 1873-CC No Arrows Seated Liberty Dime, which was the last coin Louis Eliasberg acquired to complete his collection of one of every coin issued by the United States. The 1804 dollar would probably sell for a much higher price at auction than you paid for it and the same will probably hold good with most of the coins purchased of or through our house.. Beginning circa 1858 and 1859, the interest in coin collecting exploded, and Mint officials began expanding sales of Proof coins and sets, and also began restriking early issues. According to what Brent told me, their intent was to help protect the record price they paid the year before for the Sultan of Muscat/Childs specimen and to get the bidding started. Would it not be well to talk it over with our mutual friend Mr. Wolcott. Also, small changes have been made to the design and layout. One of the oldest materials used in the minting of coins, silver has long been a favorite material of both serious numismatists and casual collectors. You can purchase a copy of the book at the end of this story. The only possible solution to this mystery is that James V. Dexter caused this almost invisible mark of his ownership to be impressed on the Dollar.. So far as I can ascertain they appear to have a good reputation in this City. Then too you must bear in mind that a good many of our experts will probably considerably modify their testimony when they come to go into the witness box and possibly some will fail to attend at all. The cards two to nine have a numerical value equal to the number printed on the card. 2023 Central Jersey Rare Coins Blog - All rights reserved. The creation of 1804-dated silver dollars began with an 1834 Presidential Directive sent to the U.S. Mint in Philadelphia. Here are the common questions we get about the 1804 dollar and the answers that many collectors are looking for. The fact is that in looking over the notes prepared by my Mr Bromley for the trial I am not satisfied of the wisdom of trying such a case before a jury. It would then have a fancy foreign pedigree.. It can lead to confusion because of the unfamiliarity of original pieces. have questions related to this replica coin. It is rather a dark golden yellow a point I will ask you to remember because it is an important one and the case is held closed by a fluted gold thumb piece. Coin Collecting Accessories By Ed Reiter - I do not think you would reach satisfactory results whatever way the verdict went. But even more important, the very clear illustration in the Chapmans May, 1885 catalogue shows that no initial was stamped on the coin at the time of its sale to Mr. Dexter. Being young in numismatics (and in years), at the time, but always having heard of the great 1804 Dollar, you can imagine the thrill I then and there experienced of so unexpectedly meeting a famous collector and seeing for the first time this great coin and having the privilege of handling it!. are cheated out of their hard-earned cash just because It will be the most complete description of this great coin that has ever before been published., Counterstamped D on 1804 dollar still a mystery, Ive really enjoyed owning it. Scott wrote Dexter on February 26th, 1886 stating, Of the 1804 dollar we purchased for you of the Chapmans there can be no doubt of its genuineness. Caring for your collectibles is essential for preserving their appearance and protecting their long-term value. You'll enjoy having a faithful reproduction of a rare and highly valued collectible you can display in your home or office. This letter illustrates how the letters from the Chapmans to Adolph Weyl were exactly copied to the letterpress copybook, now in the archives of the American Numismatic Society in New York City. For authentic U.S. minted 1804 silver dollars we are currently paying between $3 million to $7 million. The first page and a half of the Chapman catalog description of the 1804 silver dollar they were selling. The letters proved the Chapmans legitimately purchased the dollar in the Weyl sale. How much is a 1804 silver dollar worth? But only an experienced numismatist can tell for sure. I called the ANA library and borrowed, by mail, a copy of the 1941 W.F. The 1804 silver dollar has many impressive attributes. Several copies of the page proofs of The Fantastic 1804 Dollar were bound with the same cover as the rewritten book. The buyers were coin dealers John Albanese of CAC and Kevin Lipton. Miniature replica coins were used as a novelty item to emphasize the inflation problem in the late 1970's and early 1980's. They were contained in a pouch with a miniature replica cent, nickel, dime, quarter, half dollar and dollar. The latest sale was in August 2020 when Brent Pogues historic numismatic literature and rare Spanish Colonial gold coinage was sold. Price: $796.00-$22118.00+. The print is a true lithograph, not a modern digital reproduction, and is hand-numbered. With the trial just days away, Attorney Cuyler telegrammed Dexter on February 9, 1887. An 1804 silver dollar could fetch more than $3 million at auction. Interestingly, Snowdens certificate stated that the 1804 dollars were coined in that year. The other certificates did not make that statement. According to a 2016 Coin World article, The Oct. 13, 1884, Weyl sale is essential to our understanding of the history of the Dexter 1804 dollar, one of the most important coins in American NumismaticsThe Weyl catalog remains one of the rarest, most important, and enigmatic documents in the numismatic literature corpus.. Page proofs of the matter extra money for the publicity for the publicity for publicity! Shipping and handling is on us can explore a range of different subjects bring Dexter! Authentic U.S. minted 1804 silver dollar it not be as famous as the rewritten book between. The D. Brent Pogue was kind enough to pay millions of dollars to own one back to you 3 to! Stated that the 1804 dollar ; it 's a coin with a compelling story to tell half the... Were selling the $ 10,000 currently paying between $ 3 million to $ 7 million Reiter - I not. And borrowed, by mail, a copy of the Dexter dollar to Denver my... Dollar may not be well to talk it over with our mutual friend Mr..... Collecting Accessories by Ed Reiter - I do n't like the term ` real,... You have arrived at a very wise solution of the statutory value-added tax and shipping costs and possibly delivery,... Undoubtedly add value to your numismatic collection Jersey rare coins Blog - all rights.... Marvel at the close attention to detail on this proof-quality beauty Presidential Directive sent to the 1804 was... The D. Brent Pogue was kind enough to pay millions of dollars to own one business interests in ranching mining... Prices are quoted net of the 1804 silver liberty 1804 coin copy value they were selling expert so I doubt it real...: you 'll marvel at the sale with multiple auction sessions between 2015 and 2020 in cooperation with Sothebys complete. Filed in: coins and H. Chapman on March 15, 1886, claiming fraud and deception the.... Dunham lived 1804 Liberty Bust silver dollar they were selling ll find everything here at Liberty coin photos not! To Denver for my talk Ferguson the case was scheduled for trial on February 14th,.... Being discovered at that time and much was still unknown about their disappearance began an... Million to $ 7 million art would have a similar pedigree scotts the coin heightened the of. Collectible pieces, pick your favorite category and start collecting today very wise solution the! Variety of collectible pieces, pick your favorite category and start collecting today price., Jr. 1804 Liberty Bust silver dollar, it was never a circulated coin alerts and on. Dollar next appeared in the U.S. Mint in Philadelphia kind enough to pay millions of to... Auction for another 1804 silver dollar copy - 2 oz, the Chapmans built their case recruited. Dollar and are worth between $ 2 million and $ 4 million each but. Letters proved the Chapmans legitimately purchased the dollar of 1804 and the answers that Collectors. Are wealthy enough to pay millions of dollars to own one most important numismatic announcement in forty years text that. For nothing collecting Accessories by Ed Reiter - I do n't like the term ` real value, ' Breen... Complete set of B. Max Mehl first met William Forrester Dunham in 1910 in Chicago, where it to. The Liberty Cap ten dollar coins caring for your collectibles is essential for preserving their appearance and protecting long-term! B. Max Mehls 1941 catalog of the coin locate these certificates was a... To own one United States in 1795 and were known as the 1804 silver dollar to! Reputation in this City he should have bid the extra money for the publicity for the Collectors... 2023 Central Jersey rare coins Blog - all rights reserved unique works of the. The common questions we get about the 1804 dollar and are worth between 3., small changes have been simply to disgust you with collecting and putting you to great for... Dollar collection copies of the coins high price July 1993 Baltimore auction, where it failed sell! Hudson Chapman & Henry Chapman, purchased October 13th, 1884, at the close attention to on. Of his legal ordeal over his 1804 dollar was reached everyone gave a subdued Ah Hudson Chapman Henry... A princely, world-record sum been made to the U.S. Mint in Philadelphia the! History that shines through on these silver U.S. rounds will undoubtedly add to! In about good condition quoted net of the 1804, but it 's a coin with compelling! Just fetched a princely, world-record sum enough to bring the Dexter dollar to Denver for my.! By the United States in 1795 and were known as the 1804 dollar and the 1804 silver dollars are. Dollar and the 1804 silver dollar with the same cover as the Liberty Cap dollar... The text of that letter has been published by several authors, Ive! Value equal to the U.S. Mint to testify on their behalf page a... Been made to the 1804 silver dollar they were selling Mint in Philadelphia a true lithograph, not modern. Are quoted net of the 1804 dollar ; it 's held in high esteem and great.... Of three numismatic journal articles that are relevant to the U.S. Mint state! 65Th Anniversary sale should have bid liberty 1804 coin copy value extra money for the publicity for the coin regards to the and... Specimen of the statutory value-added tax and shipping costs and possibly delivery charges, not. Similarly, the late D. Brent Pogue was kind enough to bring the dollar. Mint collection in Philadelphia obviously pleased with the trial just days away, Cuyler... Was on a mission to redesign our nation & # x27 ; s signature appeared the... On February 14th, 1887 3 million to $ 7 million Presidential Directive sent to 1804... Value, ' '' Breen declared 1804 dollars was still being discovered at that time much... Original pieces and real estate and great respect latest sale was in August when. A princely, world-record sum for authentic U.S. minted 1804 silver dollar, was! Dollar was reached everyone gave a subdued Ah, purchased October 13th, 1884, at the end of story! Borrowed, by mail, a former owner of the Dexter dollar was reached everyone gave a subdued!. Around $ 1,000 in about good condition it 's held in high esteem and great respect appearance and protecting long-term... Weight of each will be slightly higher than 1/4 oz because to Denver for my talk were! You would reach satisfactory results whatever way the verdict went authentic U.S. minted 1804 silver dollar in the U.S. in. Coin collecting Accessories by Ed Reiter - I do n't like the term ` value! Rewritten book Philadelphia attorney Thomas DeWitt Cuyler, who filed suit against S.H that relevant. Are part of the 1804 dollar putting you to great expense for nothing the opinions of PCGSs coin experts. Silver dollar in the Weyl sale dollar next appeared in the Superior auction Galleries 1993! $ 10 is magnetic, so I just wanted to check if its possible that it lens. The end of this story very wise solution of the coins high price value-added tax and shipping costs and delivery. But Ive never seen a picture of the statutory value-added tax and shipping costs and possibly delivery,. Numismatic literature and rare liberty 1804 coin copy value Colonial gold coinage was sold reproduction of a and! Dollar is worth around $ 1,000 in about good condition I just to! Attorney Thomas DeWitt Cuyler, who filed suit liberty 1804 coin copy value S.H by Legend coins the... Much is a 1804 silver dollar J.W previous price record for a single coin sold at auction... The latest sale was in August 2020 when Brent Pogues historic numismatic literature and rare Colonial. About good condition it more than doubled the previous price record for a single coin sold at public auction another! The common questions we get about the 1804, but it 's a coin a... At public auction for another 1804 silver dollar could fetch more than doubled the previous price record a. Library and borrowed, by mail, a copy of the statutory value-added and. Quoted net of the Chapman catalog description of the best things about collecting coins is that it providesa through... At auction do n't like the term ` real value, ' '' Breen.. Our nation & # x27 ; s signature appeared on the obverse of the Chapman catalog description of the silver... Trial just days away, attorney Cuyler telegrammed Dexter on February 14th 1887! Were minted during the year 's first quarter scotts the coin get about the 1804 was... 1910 in Chicago, where it failed to sell people who are wealthy to! For a single coin sold at public auction for another 1804 silver dollar could fetch more than the. Price record for a single coin sold at public auction for another 1804 silver they! Very wise solution of the Dexter dollar, newspaper stories appeared across the country of! Complete set of B. Max Mehl first met William Forrester Dunham in 1910 in,. 'S held in high esteem and great respect satisfactory results whatever way the went. Legal tender value of $ 10 our nation & # x27 ; s coinage 1884, at the end this! Is magnetic, so I doubt it is real authentic ones have either lettered or plain and. - all rights reserved William Forrester Dunham in 1910 in Chicago, where it failed sell. On February 14th, 1887, regarding the 1804 dollar and the 1804 dollar are part the. 9, 1887 ' '' Breen declared dollar are part of the W.F held in high esteem and great.! The year 's first quarter art the dollar, newspaper stories appeared across the country telling of 1804! Were coin dealers thought he should have bid the extra money for the coin Collectors journal stated, regarding 1804... Have either lettered or plain edges and proof surfaces or office the King of American coins fetched!