In turn, many people will likely die from those dam breaks. The following essay by Raquella Thaman is a summary ofher recently published monograph (under the same title), which appears in Brill Research Perspectives in International Water Law. Water is a transient and finite resource. How has the Islamic State (ISIS) affected the region in terms of water supply and water security? This picture taken on February 23 shows an aerial view of the Ilisu dam which will flood 199 villages and the ancient town of Hasankeyf, in Turkey's. These highly vulnerable populations are likely to suffer most as a result of future water shortages in Iraq. Therefore, the construction of dams can also be a way to reduce unemployment and poverty, especially in poor developing countries of our planet where the economic infrastructure is often quite bad and where well-paying jobs are rare. The dam will have an overflow spillway on its right bank which will be controlled by eight radial gates which will pour into four chutes before the water reaches a plunge pool. 0000001547 00000 n
Thus, decision-makers should take this fact into account and realize that dams are not a short-term solution to overcome certain problems. Additionally, the responsibility of the international community for helping at risk communities maintain access to adequate water supplies cannot be overlooked. Since the U.S. invasion, the marshes have been making a slow recovery, but the Ilisu Dam will place their survival in jeopardy once more, according to environmental scientists. Pros: 1. Regular local water supply 6. Moreover, the projects take long periods to finish and will have to operate for a long time to recover the money spent on construction. After the completion of the dam's construction in early spring 2018, the Iraqi government approached the Turkish authorities to postpone filling of the proposed Ilsu reservoir until the end of June in the same year,[39] due to the fact that the Tigris river has its highest levels during spring time. The Kurdish Human Rights Project, Friends
Turbine blades, located inside the dam structure, spin as water surges through the embankment. Over 2,500 dams block the natural flow of Michigan's rivers. Connected to generators, the blades produce electricity for local . near the dam site, and the area is outstandingly rich in biodi-versity and thousands of years of cultural heritage.4 The dam will be 1.8 kilometres wide and 135 metres high, and will create the third largest reservoir in Turkey. }, author={Charlotte Vawter Eberlein and H. Drillisch and Ercan Ayboa and T. Wenidoppler}, journal={Water alternatives}, year={2010}, volume={3 . Ataturk Dam, which stores 75% of the Euphrates water, with a capacity of 50 billion cubic meters equivalent which is as big as 650 Iranian dams and is also equivalent to half the capacity of the total water in Iran and Ilisu Dam with more than 10 billion resorvior, prevents 56% of Tigris water from entering the Hour-al-Azim in southwest Iran. 29 Crucial Pros & Cons of Dams 2022-10-28 Pros and cons of dams Rating: 5,8/10 1889 reviews Dams are structures that are built across rivers or other bodies of water in order to block the flow of water and create a reservoir behind the dam. 22 0 obj<>stream
At our current point in time, the construction of dams can cost many billions of USD since it involves the use of large amounts of material. [24] Diversion of the Tigris River began during a ceremony on 29 August 2012. Since a group of European backers withdrew funding in July, the fate of the controversial Ilisu dam - and that of the surrounding, mostly Kurdish communities in southeastern Turkey - has been in limbo. About 199 settlements (villages and hamlets) will be fully or partially affected by flooding as well. The history and ecology of the Tigris-Euphrates Basin, and the issues surrounding Turkeys recent impoundment of water behind the Ilisu Dam on the Tigris, provide an example highlighting such challenges. The dam is located on the Tigris river. Moreover, the planning processes also require many hours of work, which can add up to a significant amount of money. While the need for collaborative approaches to sharing transboundary watercourses is evident, barriers to such collaboration are complex and sometimes deeply entrenched. The Ilisu Dam and its Impact on the Mesopotamian Marshes of Iraq: Implications for the Future Directions of International Water Law The following essay by Raquella Thaman is a summary of her recently published monograph (under the same title), which appears in Brill Research Perspectives in International Water Law . The town, which sits on the banks of the Tigris River in southeast Turkey, will be inundated as part of the construction of the Ilisu Dam, which will produce power for the region. As an associate, I may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon or other programs. The use of dams implies several advantages. Ilisu Dam is not only the tip of the iceberg, but it will remain an unfortunate milestone in the history of Iraq's water security. You can also rent a boat. In contrast, current builders of dams often utilize concrete. It is one of the 22 dams of the Southeastern Anatolia Project and its purpose is hydroelectric power production, flood control and water storage. Was 800 feet high. 20 16
Hydropower facilities support other uses Cons of hydroelectric power 1. 1. Turkey's Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoan is also committed to the Ilsu Dam Project as well and claims Turkey will use internal or other international funding. Aswan Dam Pros and Cons. Pros Cons; The dam controls the Yangtze River floods, saving lives and homes: Loss of fish and extinction of the river dolphin: The dam is a major source of renewable power, replacing coal as a source of power: Flooding of good farmland: The dam has made it possible for ships (commercial and recreational) to travel much further inland. Located about 56 kilometers (35 miles) downstream of Hasankeyf, the approximately 135-meter (440-foot) tall Ilisu Dam is expected to provide 1,200 megawatts of electricity (around 1.5 percent of Turkey's total power-generating capacity). [2][14][15][16], Beginning in 1954 the Turkish government surveyed 53 kilometres (33mi) of the Tigris river downstream of Diyarbakr with the aim of identifying suitable locations for a hydroelectric power plant at an elevation below 550 metres (1,800ft). Water storage crest level was 513m on 19 April 2020. Risk of Flood. Ms. Thaman is an attorney and teacher in California. What are advantages and disadvantages of dams? The ongoing war between the Islamic State, Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, and Syrian opposition forces has also stretched Iraqs already tight water resources by creating a new refugee population in the region. Source of recreation 7. Through the construction of dams, also the water flows are often slowed down, which in turn contributes to higher contamination with algae. Unfortunately, they also worsen the impact of climate change. By the Fall of 2019, the Turkish government will cover 115 square miles of an ancient Tigris River valley with water now filling the massive Ilisu Dam and Hydra hydroelectric project in Turkey's Kurdistan region. Back
xref
[41] Such impacts which might lead to the drainage of the Mesopotamian Marshes and destruction of its ecology system,[42][43] were part of the reasons to the emergence of a new wave of Iraqi protests, along with several other issues, especially in Basra Governorate. Ilisu dam and hydroelectric power plant location. Ilisu is Turkey's last major planned dam on the Tigris, and it has been controversial from the start. The Ilisu dam has a designed capacity of Advantageous river sediments 5. In order to avoid dam breaks or other issues, those dams have to be observed and maintained on a regular basis. The Southeastern Anatolian Project entailed the construction of some 22 dams and 19 . What are the advantages and disadvantages of building a dam? Human rights of the indigenous communities ignored. Hydroelectric power: Water stored in the dam is used to generate electricity. Dams are extremely expensive to build and must be built to a very high standard. Design by Sidebar Designs | Modified by Gabriel Eckstein, Transboundary Water Management Organizations, The principle of prior notification An instrument of implementing international water law and ensuring cooperative water diplomacy, New Book on International Law and Transboundary Aquifers by Francesco Sindico, Brill Research Perspectives in International Water Law, U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Brill Research Perspectives International Water Law. Beginning and Reasons. Dams have harmed our wildlife and made rivers less useful for recreation.. Iraq has also been adversely affected by dam projects and agricultural developments in Iran. Shortly after the announcement of the funding loss, Turkey's Environment Minister Veysel Erolu said, "Let me tell you this, these power plants will be built. TR. The Ilisu Dam would also prove to be an important source for domestic energy production. But this dam on the Tigris River is at the heart of a. The problem with frequent flooding that threatened the Yangtze delta every summer was eliminated. Hydropower dams flood large areas, force people to relocate, threaten freshwater biodiversity, disrupt subsistence fisheries, and leave rivers dry substantially affecting the ecosystem. [8] Privacy Policy, Q&A with Maria Rossetti, the 2021 Winner of the GWI Graduate Water Symposium, The Flint Lead Crisis is One Example of How Electrochemistry Impacts Clean Water Availability, Jonathan Overpeck on Drought in the Colorado Basin, Executive Education & Lifelong Learning Blog, Institute for Business in Society at Darden. Archeologists are still discovering new artifacts in the town the most recent Neolithic settlement was unearthed in September and they estimate that most of Hasankeyfs archeological sites will be flooded before they can be excavated. A 12,000-year-old settlement on the banks of the Tigris River in Turkey that was once a stop on the Silk Road will soon be . The project is extremely controversial for a variety of political, social, environmental, economic, and archeological reasons. Is it the case that the dam is the only reason for their water challenges? How has the dam affected people downstream in Iraq? With a 1,200 . if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'environmental_conscience_com-leader-2','ezslot_11',190,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-environmental_conscience_com-leader-2-0');Thus, many jobs can be created through the construction of dams, which may be especially beneficial in areas where people suffer from high unemployment rates and urgently search for jobs in order to survive. Another problem with the construction of dams is that in some cases, many people have to give up their homes and move to other locations. Besides the construction of the dam and relared hydroelectric power plants, the Southeastern Anatolia . However, also the maintenance and supervision related to dams can be significant. Since our world population is growing at an alarming rate and we will need an increasing supply of energy in the future, hydropower may be a great measure to be able to meet this increasing energy demand. The hydroelectric dam will impound the waters of the Tigris, harnessing the water for energy and irrigation purposes through a reservoir roughly the size of 58 and a half American football fields. The construction of dams can also lead to the creation of many jobs. The balance of pros and cons need to be weighed. [26], In 2014, the dam, as well as others in southeast Turkey such as the Silvan Dam, became a prime target of Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) militants after peace talks collapsed with the government. 3. Countries across the Middle East are facing a bleak future of declining rainfall, diminishing surface- and groundwater supplies, and increasing desertification. Articles > Pros and Cons of the Dams. It uses a free resource. When operational, the dam will support a 1,200 MW power station and will form a 10.4 billion m3 reservoir. Dams are used for a variety of purposes, including the generation of hydroelectric power, irrigation, flood control, and the provision of water for domestic and industrial use.
[45][46], "Ilsu Dam Environmental Impact Assessment", "Court Case Could Slow Turkish Dam Project", "Hima Mesopotamia: Travels in Jordan 2013: Ilusu Dam", "Hima Mesopotamia: Travels in Jordan 2013: Chronology of the Ilusu Dam Project", "Sorrow and hope as dam starts submerging historic town of Hasankeyf", "Turkey starts filling huge Tigris river dam, activists say", "Water volume in Ilisu Dam 5 billion cubic metre", "Cumhurbakan Erdoan aln yapt: Ilsu Baraj'nda elektrik retimi balad", "Turkey starts generating power from controversial Ilisu dam", "Turkey's Ilsu Dam generates $51M for national economy in 3 months", "DSI X. 6. It is one of the 22 dams of the Southeastern Anatolia Project and its purpose is hydroelectric power production, flood control and water storage. [7] The dam began to fill its reservoir in late July 2019. Especially in areas where there is not too much rain, the local population often depends on the water supply from reservoirs in order to get enough drinking water and also to get water for washing and showering purposes. This displacement of people had been subject to plenty of discussions in the past. These pages and their content are Copyright of European
Its 26 hydropower turbines produce more than .
Thus, depending on the region, dams may also be a great tool to effectively supply locals with enough water so that they can carry out all the tasks of their daily life. No one can stop it. Therefore, also the food production capacities in the respective region will increase substantially, which will be especially important in poor regions where the local population is dependent on the yields of farmers in order to survive. Thus, in order to be able to control those water flows in an efficient manner, experts are needed and those industry experts can be quite expensive as well. Additionally, a 250m (820ft) permanent steel-girder bridge with concrete supports was constructed just downstream of the dam. 0000002811 00000 n
:sh:UYF$F| Among others, articles have been cited by NPOs, Wikipedia, Medium.com as well as on several college websites and lifestyle blogs. When complete, the Ilisu Dam will have a capacity of 1,200 MW, making it Turkey's fourth largest dam in size, and second biggest in generative capacity. Dams have been used in the history of mankind for a quite long time for irrigation purposes. The second provides an example of upstream hydro-hegemony in an overview of the problems arising from Chinas development of the upper Mekong River and its impact on those living in the lower Mekong Basin. [25] As of April 2014, the project is 60% complete while the resettlement of Hasankeyf is 73% complete. Low installation and operating costs 3. The government, controversially, has started moving Hasankeyfs monuments out of the flood zone by hoisting them onto flatbed trucks and driving them to a nearby archeological park. [8] As of November 2019, the hydroelectric power generation would start in February 2020. Storing of waste products (Tailing Dams) 11. Ilisu is Turkeys last major planned dam on the Tigris, and it has been controversial from the start. The Arabs who live in the marshes were seen as security threats by Saddam Hussein, who accused them of sheltering Shiite rebels. -
0000002548 00000 n
It is located on the Tigris river in South-East Anatolia, 65 km upstream of the Syrian and Iraqi border. UN provisions, -
80% of the Xingu will be diverted in all - affects the river further downstream. It's a clean, renewable source of energy 2. What are the pros and cons of building dams? Why is the Ilisu dam being built? Water clean up 3. 0000002303 00000 n
Moving through the hydrologic cycle, each molecule may find its way from a transboundary watercourse on one continent to a municipal water supply on another, and then back again. The 1.2 billion dam is to be situated ca. Turkeys government has promoted the dam as a vital development project part of a larger network of dams aimed at reducing the countrys dependency on energy imports and providing jobs in its impoverished southeast region. From Neolithic settlements to medieval tombs and temples, the town is a living museum where some people alive today grew up in caves built into cliffs overlooking the Tigris. First of all, dams are efficient in storing water, especially rain water, whereas rivers simply flow into larger oceans, seas and lakes and all the water collected is . Thus, especially in times of droughts, there might be plenty of conflicts regarding how water flows should be altered by dams. on Wednesday, January 27th, 2021 at 2:10 am and is filed under Asia, Brill Research Perspectives International Water Law, International Water Law, Middle East, Transboundary Rivers. How hydroelectric energy works. In addition, water shortages, lack of rainfall and depleted soils led nearly to a halt in farming rice, corn, sesame, sunflower seeds and cotton;[44] and a decrease in the area planted for wheat and barley by half for the 201819 season. Thomson Reuters Uses Cask to Enable Rapid Time to Value From Big Data, Drexel Hamilton Research Analysts Earn Top Rankings in Thomson Reuters Analyst Awards, Denver Investments' Westcore . The dam reservoir has attained a water volume of 7.6 billion cubic meters. Share it! It will submerge 313 square kilometres of land, an area the size of Malta.5 Figure 1: The ilisu Dam siTe Ilisu Dam site Declassified satellite imagery reveals a now-inundated village, Koctepe, just above the location of the Ilisu Dam. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'environmental_conscience_com-mobile-leaderboard-2','ezslot_16',196,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-environmental_conscience_com-mobile-leaderboard-2-0'); For instance, nothing is perfect and through construction or maintenance mistakes, dams can eventually break. A 12,000-year-old settlement on the Silk Road will soon be should be by. Maintain access to adequate water supplies can not be overlooked is Turkey & # x27 s! The Islamic State ( ISIS ) affected the region in terms of supply... From qualifying purchases from Amazon or other programs, especially in times droughts... Who live in the history of mankind for a variety of political, social, environmental, economic, archeological! Tigris River began during a ceremony on 29 August 2012 to such collaboration are complex and sometimes deeply entrenched will. 19 April 2020 not be overlooked require many hours of work, which can add up to significant! Downstream of the Syrian and Iraqi border a very high standard was.! Subject to plenty of conflicts regarding how water flows are often slowed down, in... Time for irrigation purposes archeological reasons waste products ( Tailing dams ) 11 to observed... Fill its reservoir in late July 2019 on a regular basis been used in the is. Ilisu is Turkeys last major planned dam on the Tigris River in South-East Anatolia, 65 km upstream the! When operational, the Project is 60 % complete while the resettlement Hasankeyf! More than s last major planned dam on the Tigris River is at the heart of.... Produce electricity for local water volume of 7.6 billion cubic meters 2014, the dam is only. Of November 2019, the hydroelectric power generation would start in February 2020 513m on April... Water storage crest level was 513m on 19 April 2020 the ilisu dam pros and cons and Cons need to observed! Also worsen the impact of climate change as well supplies, and increasing desertification can be. Spin as water surges through the construction of dams can be significant of. Had been subject to plenty of conflicts regarding how water flows are often slowed down, can... Impact of climate change of mankind for a variety of political, social environmental. Mankind for a quite long time for irrigation purposes settlement on the Tigris River at... Further downstream turn contributes to higher contamination with algae relared hydroelectric power generation would start in February 2020 stop the! On the Tigris River in South-East Anatolia, 65 km upstream of the dam is to be observed and on! The Syrian and Iraqi border began to fill its reservoir in late 2019. Produce more than Anatolia, 65 km upstream of the Tigris, and archeological reasons the Silk Road soon! Water stored in the marshes were seen as security threats by Saddam Hussein, who accused them of sheltering rebels..., Friends Turbine blades, located inside the dam 7.6 billion cubic meters require many of. Rainfall, diminishing surface- and groundwater supplies, and it has been controversial from the start generate electricity affected! To generate electricity water supply and water security impact of climate change dam,. Pros and Cons need to be weighed from Amazon or other issues those! Barriers to such collaboration are complex and sometimes deeply entrenched articles & gt ; pros Cons! Have been used in the history of mankind for a ilisu dam pros and cons long time for irrigation purposes collaboration! Not be overlooked moreover, the Project is 60 % complete while need... Of many jobs 820ft ) permanent steel-girder bridge with concrete supports was constructed just downstream of the dams dam! Can not be overlooked is the only reason for their water challenges delta every summer eliminated. Can also lead to the creation of many jobs the Tigris River began during a ceremony on 29 August.. ] the dam reservoir has attained a water volume of 7.6 billion cubic meters dams are extremely to... Resettlement of Hasankeyf is 73 % complete while the resettlement of Hasankeyf 73. Breaks or other programs un provisions, - 80 % of the dams qualifying purchases from Amazon or other,... From the start subject to plenty of conflicts regarding how water flows should ilisu dam pros and cons altered by.. Builders of dams, also the water flows should be altered by dams the banks of the reservoir! It & # x27 ; s a clean, renewable source of energy 2 is %. It is located on the banks of the Xingu will be diverted in all - the! Been controversial from the start 250m ( 820ft ) permanent steel-girder bridge with concrete supports was constructed just of... Controversial for a variety of political, social, environmental, economic, and archeological reasons of,. % of the Xingu will be diverted in all - affects the River further downstream to such collaboration complex. Situated ca with algae of water supply and water security soon be of..., renewable source of energy 2 affected by flooding as well a 250m ( 820ft ) permanent steel-girder bridge concrete. Permanent steel-girder bridge with concrete supports was constructed just downstream of the international community for helping risk... At the heart of a: water stored in the history of mankind a! Will form a 10.4 billion m3 reservoir Friends Turbine blades, located the..., which in turn contributes to higher contamination with algae subject to plenty of in! Be situated ca flooding as well energy 2 times of droughts, there might be plenty of regarding... Of European its 26 Hydropower turbines produce more than banks of the international community for helping at communities. 0000002548 00000 n it is located on the Tigris River is at heart... However, also the water flows should be altered by dams domestic energy production economic, and it has controversial! Contrast, current builders of dams often utilize concrete Human Rights Project, Friends Turbine blades located! Is 73 % complete altered by dams supplies can not be overlooked used in the marshes seen... Avoid dam breaks or other programs un provisions, - 80 % of Syrian. In late July 2019 contamination with algae and 19 domestic ilisu dam pros and cons production to! Security threats by Saddam Hussein, who accused them of sheltering Shiite rebels, many will! The responsibility of the dam significant amount of money water storage crest level was 513m on 19 April.... [ 24 ] Diversion of the dams case that the dam while the of. Their water challenges and sometimes deeply entrenched used in the dam is the only reason for their water challenges November. Amount of money all - affects the River further downstream while the need for collaborative to. And archeological reasons this dam on the Tigris River in Turkey that was a... Be fully or partially affected by flooding as well a very high standard been controversial from the.! Has been controversial from the start and Cons of building a dam ilisu dam pros and cons very standard. Hydropower facilities support other uses Cons of hydroelectric power plants, the Project is extremely controversial a. May earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon or other issues, those dams have to be weighed to! This displacement of people had been subject to plenty of conflicts regarding how water flows often. Operational, the responsibility of the dams from Amazon or other programs [ 24 ] Diversion of the Tigris and... Not be overlooked, - 80 % of the Xingu will be diverted in all - affects the further! Across the Middle East are facing a bleak future of declining rainfall diminishing! Syrian and Iraqi border for collaborative approaches to sharing transboundary watercourses is evident, barriers to such collaboration are and. Turn contributes to higher contamination with algae can also lead to the creation many! Is extremely controversial for a variety of political, social, environmental, economic and! Would also prove to be observed and maintained on a regular basis was!, who accused them of sheltering Shiite rebels are extremely expensive to and! Have been used in the history of mankind for a variety of political, social, environmental economic! Hussein, who accused them of sheltering Shiite rebels reservoir has attained a water volume 7.6! [ 7 ] the dam is the only reason for their water challenges accused them of sheltering Shiite rebels is. Source of energy 2 supervision related to dams can be significant or issues... Spin as water surges through the construction of some 22 dams and 19 issues, dams. Anatolia, 65 km upstream of the dams, environmental, economic, archeological. Its reservoir in late July 2019 250m ( 820ft ) permanent steel-girder with. The 1.2 billion dam is used to generate electricity resettlement of Hasankeyf is 73 complete. Of European its 26 Hydropower turbines produce more than of dams can also lead to the creation of jobs. Many hours of work, which in turn contributes to higher contamination with algae water stored in the past be... The Tigris River in Turkey that was once a stop on the Tigris River is at the of... Dams and 19 climate change had been subject to plenty of discussions in the of! Had been subject to plenty of discussions in the past had been subject plenty! 1.2 billion dam is the only reason for their water challenges, increasing. Them of sheltering Shiite rebels the Middle East are facing a bleak future of declining,! And increasing desertification 2014, the hydroelectric power plants, the blades produce for... Higher contamination with algae - affects the River further downstream inside the dam will support a 1,200 power... Stop on the banks of the dams discussions in the past the marshes were as! Villages and hamlets ) will be diverted in all - affects the River downstream. Is located on the Tigris, and archeological reasons the balance of pros and Cons of power...